Scobleizer - Latest Comments in Why I’m in a malaise…

Re: Why I’m in a malaise…

Tech Bee — Wed, 30 May 2007 11:39:49 -0000

May I chime in? I know what you mean. I'm feeling it too in France. It's the "suits". When guys in suits came to see what bloggers picnics were about, you knew times were a-changing. I trace the sea change to the YouTube/Google deal.

Re: Why I’m in a malaise…

RacefanPat — Fri, 25 May 2007 09:41:32 -0000

As a small-time (mature age) student, and recent tech fanatic (read 5-ish years) I have noticed the decline from true innovation as headlines, to the present trend of copying anything successfull, and the multitude of "similar" boutique products.

I have a few thougts as to why the current glut of really cool, but boutique, or niche products, depress pple like you.

The sheeer volume of inovation, and the ammount of takeover activity of best-in-field, re-inforces this to me. Following is an example (ME) of why the more things accelerate, the more they stay the same. I am an early-adopter & tester. But, I have a limited ammount of time, and a lot of passion to absorb... stuff.

So why do I think a bust is coming?
Why do I think Robert Scoble is exasberated?
Why will most start-ups fail, (as in the last bust)?

One reason M'soft and Google (as the most obvious EXAMPLES) will succeed and others fail in the inevitable "bust", (which is really just an economic consolidation in any other feild), is beacuse of their sheer size (financialy and product breadth), and therefore capacity to COPY, or emulate a wide variety of products, and therefore pick up users like me. Note: I don't believe either are particulariy great INOVATORS, although both DO, but producing acceptable competitors is just as profitable...

I love so many products, but I keep going back to a single login at google.

WHY.

1. Great email, with availability wherever I am...
2. Reader, ONE of the best, available anywhere, and (with a few scripts) integrated with mail...
3. Calander... integrated with mail, and flexible (also using a few scripts)
4. igoogle, one stop-shop...
5. Desktop, (Which I Love) avails me of the ability to search across my computers...

Absolutely none is a killer app. (well Mabye reader, as I HATE most of the client apps and love the cross-computer availability); But with google docs, Picasa (Which I love) and other products, I have an integrated, worldwide available, single log-in AND with a laptop and PC, as well as using Uni and other computers, if I back-up current docs, bookmarks, and so-on I can acess them any-where.

Interestingly, (as an Aussie Student) I recently downloaded MS Office 2007 Ultimate for a few dollars, and I am really liking the tools in it. However I still find collaboration and so-on easier with google. HOWEVER, they now have a pretty complete package for even a casual user. BUT I paid $75_00, and would never pay the list $1150... So even the nearest comp loses easily.

Probably not one of the Google apps will ever be best in field, but if I go on holidays and get on a freinds computer, I sign on once...

Re: Why I’m in a malaise…

macbeach — Wed, 23 May 2007 17:11:32 -0000

I agree with some previous advice that less output would be a good idea. Maybe less input too.

Do you *really* need to be the most prolific Google Reader user to find interesting things to write about? I don't even have time to follow along in your Link blog and I'm semi-retired.

As far as relevance goes, you need to avoid reporting on some things, but I don't think it has to do with product endorsements, advertising, etc. Two examples:

Popfly: a very early Alpha test, not working yet, or well, or available to most people who read your blog about it and still don't know what the heck is so great about it. Microsoft is trying to become web-savvy. Great. What people are interested in is actual working examples that they can actually turn this stuff out. My guess is you still have some personal allegiance to MS that puts their stuff closer to the top of the list than it should be.

Then there was that product that found you in the lobby of the Web 3 conference (juke? joof? zoop? who can keep up these days?)... the guys from Florida, who's new, unheard of product could roll just about everybody else's product together onto one web page. Sounded almost too good to be true. And was. I signed up. Got the reminders in the mail. Got the "One day early" access, which overloaded their servers. Got the message that they were seriously re-working the service for performance and would hear from them later. "Later" has come and gone. And I've already forgotten the name of the product and deleted the old e-mails.

Probably would have been better for their company/product and for your readers/viewers if this thing were closer to production and you had already seen a preview of it before the several hundred people (many of whom probably blogged about it themselves) all jumped onto the not-ready-for-prime-time service at once.

If you mention one good/interesting thing every few days that I haven't already heard of it is probably worth visiting your blog to find out about it. If on the other hand I give away my e-mail address for one thing after another that never even launches, I'm probably better off not relying on your picks. The S/N ratio hasn't gotten unbearable yet, but it has gotten worse.

Throttling back would probably be a good idea on many levels.

Re: Why I’m in a malaise…

ChrisH — Tue, 22 May 2007 22:58:04 -0000

I like what Paul Fabretti wrote above.

Also, Robert. You say "with a kid on the way". A fascinating expression. Seems almost to contain some denial of what's really happening. It's not a kid: it's a baby. A baby is on the way. Babies are a lot more immediate than kids. Kids arte something you have i a few years time (when the babies grow up). "Kids" sounds easier than "babies".

Maybe it's a guy thing. (Can't remember what I used to say. I've got four school age kids)

Maybe women have babies and guys have kids.

Re: Why I’m in a malaise…

Nomar Garciaparra — Tue, 22 May 2007 22:45:25 -0000

Most web 2.0 sites are crap and won't stick around. Everyone knows this, but you dont need to be an elitist and get angry because Arrington got angry. Aww everyone likes the local band that i liked FIRST. Wah wah. Sure there are a lot of douchebags who only cared about Tech when they read from their real estate or telecom office that Youtube or Myspace got acquired. And now we have to deal with them. Most of them are idiots and lets hope they leave soon, but some of them are as excited about new technology as you are, maybe more.

They havent had their head cooking in front of a CRT monitor for 15 years; maybe they have some new insight and ideas.

But tech companies are not for people who just want to make big money, and those people are easy to spot and will tell you their desires very quickly. Its for people who actually care about software, hardware, the web--- people who loved it and used it and lived it before it was sexy or the next goldmine. Screw them, they'll jump on the next passing ship anyways.

Re: Why I’m in a malaise…

Eric Rice — Tue, 22 May 2007 22:25:00 -0000

Paul, probably because the geeks look to esoteric to the everyday people (and might get severely rejected big time) and the everyday people look like mundane, culture-less and pedestrian.

Both sides are probably right, and it's always amusing when one side takes control. Hell part of the reason I love mySpace is because of how irritated geek snobs get at how horrible it all looks.

Damn kids today!

Re: Why I’m in a malaise…

paulfabretti — Tue, 22 May 2007 17:17:13 -0000

The current climate is being ruined by the very people who created it. Blogs, wikis, twitter, jaiku, sphere, technorati...all created by a geek community keen to cash in on its ability to create software or programs that VC's would pay money for.

The result is that very few of these "technologies" have any stickinesss, being nothing but a passing phase. There is no built-in longevity.

As a result, many of them never make the mainstream. Geeks are quite simply producing ideas for other geeks, never giving the "mainstream public" the time or chance to watch, learn and implement one idea before the next "big idea" comes along.

Just because people buy online doesn't mean they live online.

Re: Why I’m in a malaise…

Harvey Kwan — Tue, 22 May 2007 16:44:22 -0000

what is with you guys? one blogger writes that he/she is depressed & the rest follow suit? its what i always assumed about this echo chamber mentality. you just blather on and repeat what the other guys say. a complete waste of originality.

know what? i'm going to be ecstatic that you and arrington and the rest take "a breather." you won't be missed

Re: Why I’m in a malaise…

Marshall Kirkpatrick — Tue, 22 May 2007 16:32:48 -0000

I'm having a great time, myself. The weather's nice in Portland, the web apps are fun and trust me, we're not drowning in money.

Re: Why I’m in a malaise…

Renee Blodgett — Tue, 22 May 2007 16:20:32 -0000

I agree with Robert - I’m not sure I agree that its better to go back. What I do agree with is the need for stronger BS meters and listening to opinions from those outside our industry for regular reality checks.

Re: Why I’m in a malaise…

Eric Rice — Tue, 22 May 2007 15:35:46 -0000

As a lifelong resident and native to Silicon Valley, please allow me to remind everyone that it's not just about software (I'll be generous and be more general than 'web').

From our heritage to our future, we are technology, from hardware to biology and everything in between-- and software is part of that.

Why are there so many powerful companies anchored here, like computer makers, chip makers, search engines and more?

Why is this one of those world targets for terror attacks? It's not because of the 43rd consecutive launch of a social media site.

It's far, far, far bigger than that.

That is the key.

Re: Why I’m in a malaise…

something2chewon — Tue, 22 May 2007 15:14:44 -0000

You're burning out.....find a hobby, take a vacation here to Port Angeles.
Blog for fun, fun fun fun.
Blog with geeks, blog for weeks
Blog with marbles in your cheeks
Blog your troubled life away
but don't forget that blogs are play.

Re: Why I’m in a malaise…

Ken Gardner — Tue, 22 May 2007 14:48:28 -0000

Robert,

I have a pretty simple comment. The money is a side effect of successfully creating something new. Adoption equals revenue or equals attention (which these days turns into revenue). At that point the idea has a life of its own. I have been around this for a long time now and I can remember listening to early users of IRC complain about instant messaging or users of The Well talk about how special that early community was.

We are all in the change business but sometimes that process grinds up some very special experiences. Don't worry. More special things are on the way. Like everything, we don't own these experiences and we cannot hold onto them.

Take a day off and look at the ocean instead of a computer.

Re: Why I’m in a malaise…

Curt Hopkins — Tue, 22 May 2007 14:15:14 -0000

Not being a techie guy, the Interknob and recently social media, has always been a tool to me, not an end in itself. Most important to me is poetry, fiction, drama, and the other heap of decidedly unhip, nontech stuff. The technology gave me a way to reach out, to convincingly and easily take the fruits of my feverish head and make them a part of the real world. I have to say that from that point of view, it's really never been better. I may never get HBJ to publish a 250-page novel in metrical verse on a metaphysical painter and racism but as long as I can rely on Morpheme Tales to do so, I'm always going to be a little happier than I would have been without it. From an insider's p.o.v. could be a little grim, from us garage tinkerers, it's never been better.

Re: Why I’m in a malaise…

Sam Sethi — Tue, 22 May 2007 14:13:05 -0000

I would counter this with the words a lull before the storm. The Valley has been going hell for leather for the best part of two years on the Web 2.0 bandwagon.

Now it needs a break and in many ways us Europeans are just warming up with Web, Mobile, IPTV startups.

Web 3.0 or whatever we will call it will soon appear with GData, Microformats and other stuff. The Valley will see new companies beyond just social networks appear with new models and new energy. It's not a bubble but it might need a breather or we will see more stupid deals like MSFT paying $6bn for aQunita.

If they were going to pay that much why didn't they bid for DoubleClick all the way. And how big is the MSFT war-chest? Who else will they buy now that they have woken up. i.e Tellme, aQuinita

More to the point who should they buy? Yahoo should buy Zimbra and Technorati. As I said the Web 2.0 era is far from over as the big boys step in to buy up the market.

Bring on Web 3.0 and let the fun begin again!!!

Re: Why I’m in a malaise…

Chris — Tue, 22 May 2007 14:12:33 -0000

I hadn't read the rest of the comments until now.

No startup is going to make or break on what Robert Scoble says about them. If you have a winning developer team and plenty of money behind it, count that as being way ahead of a positive critique from Mr. Scoble. You can flat out purchase very cheap marketing on something called adwords.

Re: Why I’m in a malaise…

John Dowdell — Tue, 22 May 2007 13:58:23 -0000

"The stakes are going up. Not for me, I really don’t care. But for the people I’m writing about and who want access to my audience."

This is the part of "corporate blogging" that you might not have had time to fully experience, back when Microsoft hired you to "start blogging". It's one thing for an isolated individual to write whatever they think; it's another for an individual who is also a member of a group to find something useful to say. When parachuting into Microsoft it took time to learn the other members of your group... here, you're seeing the other interests right from the start.

I bet your case is particularly hard, with lots of people trying to touch you up for sending some public attention their way. Do some people see you for your function in the blogging ecology, rather than for the person you actually are...?

Re: Why I’m in a malaise…

Dick Carlson — Tue, 22 May 2007 13:43:19 -0000

Wow -- if you're tired from writing about all these topics, imagine us (the readers) and how overwhelmed we are.

I've actually felt guilty that I rarely watch any of your videos anymore, because I just don't have room in my head for one more "way cool thing" that might grow into something. I'd encourage you as others above -- return to writing more about concepts and issues. If someone wants you to write about them, have THEM make a 5-minute video and post it to YouTube.

If it gets "X" number of comments, then you feature them. Let the market decide.

(I did like the part of the WSJ article about the CEO crying on the phone. Those are the kids who took my lunch money in junior high.)

Re: Why I’m in a malaise…

howard lindzon — Tue, 22 May 2007 13:32:56 -0000

Man do you love yourself Robert.

get over it. Get original.

Re: Why I’m in a malaise…

John C. Welch — Tue, 22 May 2007 13:16:45 -0000

Robert, there's no requirement other than the voices in your head making you post as relentlessly as you think you must. Your S/N ratio has, honestly, been getting steadily worse, but then again, now you don't have Microsoft feeding you a steady diet of topics.

You're going to have to post less, but say more or else reading your stuff is going to be pointless, since all it will be is a list of "crap robert read today", and you can find that all over the place.

Re: Why I’m in a malaise…

gwhiz — Tue, 22 May 2007 12:56:57 -0000

Wow... advice day (and thanks for keeping the comments open despite your battle with the spammers!).

Grandpa gave me two bits of guiding advice:

1) Do what you love and the money will follow. (So far, so good.)
2) Pay yourself first... meaning savings. (AWESOME advice!)

I had an overabundance of opportunities in a new gig in 1997. It was, simply put, overwhelming. And a management consultant spent a lot of effort with me on my time management style in early 1999. Know what the outcome of that was? The bet way to manage this crud is to say "No". Read Harvey McKay, Drucker, Covey, Peters, Merlin, whoever... Just say, "No." It's hard, it ruffles feathers. But, the person who's really passionate about what they're proposing isn't going to take "No." They're going to pester the bejesus out of you. THOSE *ARE* the people you want to seriously consider committing to. Not a given. Just they believe in what they're asking of you. Everyone else may have fine ideas. They just lack passion and determination to bust through. Know the difference and you'll stay the star you've already become!

Re: Why I’m in a malaise…

Bob Walsh — Tue, 22 May 2007 12:46:35 -0000

Robert,

I'd bet a good chunk of what you're feeling right now is information fatigue pure and simple. It's a real and common affliction that reporters and bloggers, tech people and online people suffer from. And you're all four! There is a finite amount of information, and decisions about information, you can comfortably process in a given period.

If I had one overall solution, that would be my next book (g), but in the meantime, a few suggestions/ideas:

1. Find people you trust and divvy out some of your feed foraging to them - I'll volunteer re microISVs (Michael L. will vouch for me), but you need a circle of people doing what you're doing re google shared feeds. (we used to call them editors back in the day.) BTW - I'm using yours to cut my information diet - Thank you!

2. Clean up loose ends - how are you wrapping your stories? In GTD parlance, are you doing a postmortem re final takeaway, lessons learned, who to follow and putting that into some sort of trusted system? Are you closing the open circuits you're constantly creating? It's not just GTD - every professional reporter I know does this too.

3. Know your newshole. That was the slice of the newspaper you own and you're expected to fill to keep your job. Nowadays its understanding how many really good stories you can video/blog in a month. Slot them - and leave time and mental energy to step back from your "beat" and see the bigger picture.

Cheers,

Re: Why I’m in a malaise…

Chris — Tue, 22 May 2007 12:43:42 -0000

When you referred to social networking, I assumed you were talking about FOAF stuff like Friendster and Hi5, and not blogs.

Journals existed far before 2002, but you're right, they became popular about around that time. I wouldn't call them social networks though, because there is no group of contacts or anything to maintain online relationships in a blog format.

If you were to interpret what you wrote as the real pioneers of social networking being small coffee shop types that came together for the sake of computing, and not for total greed, I would still say that's inaccurate.

I am not up to date on how blogging became popularized, so that's another story.

Re: Why I’m in a malaise…

Sam Jackson — Tue, 22 May 2007 12:40:54 -0000

You can write about grander things, and Vision, and that works just as well as the grimy nuts and bolts.

Re: Why I’m in a malaise…

dan — Tue, 22 May 2007 12:33:08 -0000

Its called WORK Scoble... get to it.