-
Website
http://www.scobleizer.com/ -
Original page
http://scobleizer.com/2006/01/12/microsoft-to-abandon-mac-player/ -
Subscribe
All Comments -
Community
-
Top Commenters
-
danja
44 comments · 4 points
-
polizeros
52 comments · 1 points
-
AndyBeard
69 comments · 4 points
-
Zachary Adam Cohen
35 comments · 8 points
-
dbarefoot
40 comments · 3 points
-
-
Popular Threads
-
World-brand-building mistakes France’s entrepreneurs make
2 weeks ago · 181 comments
-
The best and worst thing Twitter did in 2009: RT
3 days ago · 24 comments
-
2010: the year SEO isn’t important anymore
1 week ago · 67 comments
-
iPhone developers abandoning app model for HTML5?
1 week ago · 52 comments
-
A new addition here: the Meebo bar
2 days ago · 8 comments
-
World-brand-building mistakes France’s entrepreneurs make
As for the replacement Flip4Mac plugins to view wmv content - they suck too. Now, immediately after encountering MS proprietary content, Safari crashes (it never crashed like that before).
Face it, MS doesn't get media. Please exit the market at once for the benefit of the users. Ditto the browser. Thanks.
Now we've gotta decide what to do on Channel 9. I see MPG4 in our future!
I really don't like having multiple pieces of software that do the same thing. Which is why I chose a multi-protocol IM client like Adium (www.adiumx.com) over iChat for text based chat.
I think this is a step in the right direction.
A WMP written in OS X's native development environment would be very well accepted. Real Mac users can spot a poorly ported App from a mile away.
Hint: Google's Earth for Mac is also a Windows port, not native and looks just as ugly as WMP9.
We can't expect support from the big guy's, but some day Mac users will eherit the earth and those who wrote native apps will be given the best fate in the newly named: Appletopia.
Why Microsoft and the Mac business unit can not make a Windows Media Player that plays back content as smoothly and rich as Flip4Mac does is beyond me.
I will support Flip4Mac and I look forward to more improvements in their player. Flip4Mac's clear superiority over Microsoft's "Windows Media Player" is yet another reason why I no longer use Microsoft products.
WMP for Mac was, simply, awful....IN THE EYES OF MAC USERS.
It didn't allow them to access Windows DRM, it failed more often than not when connecting to online content (even without DRM) and it was less featured, more buggy and uglier than the Windows version. I reckon the team was under-resourced, under-motivated and for a long time, under a big axe. IIRC it wasn't part of the Mac Business Unit which does get a lot of (grudging) respect from the Mac loons out there.
I think it's a mistake to exit it, but MS has a habit of exiting markets where they just don't seem to be gaining traction. It was nice of them to license the Flip4Mac plug-ins but it's crashed Quicktime, Safari and Finder in a matter of hours....
Let's see what tomorrow brings. Looking forward to your report.
There are many applications that crash on a Windows system.
Too many.
I blame the platform, not the applications.
:-)
I don't understand how this can be a good move for Microsoft. Enough content creation happens on the Mac for it to be platform worth supporting.
It must make more sense for them to licence flip than to fix the mess that was WMP, and watching WMV using just another codec in QT is a great bonus, even with the bugs - makes C9 more useful to me at least.
Thanks Microsoft, proves that not everything you do it wrong :)
It has everything to do with DRM. Flip4Mac is NOT a long term DRM solution. Has MSFT pledged to bring their DRM and client-side scripting/interactivity capabilities to OSX via Flip4Mac? Of course not.
It's, first and foremost, MSFT denying its own customers who provide digital content the ability to offer xplatform distribution. It's a way to lock them into a Windows-only solution. It's an unabashed salvo against Apple's FairPlay. Pure and simple.
I use itunes for my Media files, and while it does seem to be slow(I don't think apple minds this) it still is much simpler to use than WMP. on my Pc WMP is very fast, but not very well organized.
Ding! Ding! Ding!
Which is kind of absurd, considering FairPlay is cross-platform. It's kind of ironic that Microsoft is going to such great lengths to prove that it's an open platform with Office 12's new format, yet it's pulling an egregious lock-in move with digital media.
I'm a huge fan of Office on OSX - on the whole, it's damn nice and the MacBU has my gratitude. Virtual PC is also essential for me. Like every other software company ever, Microsoft makes some great software and ... some not so great software. Unlike Office and other Microsoft apps on OSX (save IE), WMP was stillborn - craptastic interface, slow, buggy and feature-incomplete. It drives me nuts that I can watch EVERY OTHER PIECE OF MEDIA ON THE INTERNET save WMV in my browser and that my only other option is to pay for a buggy plug-in.
This is sacrificing users for a market share ploy. Sad, but what can you do? Open source developers can create something like VLC on 20 different platforms for free, but Microsoft can't get a working client on the Mac in 5 years? Hmph.
Hahahaha. WMP is what I've always used when people whine, "Waaah. Why can't my iPod play WMA! Why doesn't iTunes Music Store open up to others?"
This is why. I can't get a Windows media file to play worth a damn on my Mac. Give Microsoft even a foothold into that market and watch Mac support wither away. Sigh.
You know, it's really nothing against Microsoft. They're not running a charity and exclusivity sells copies of Windows. Market giants, by nature, dictate certain things. I just wish they'd stop stepping all over my little Apple village.
Mac users cant have access to all the existing Microsoft DRM based services like downloading music and video on demand.
In France the major TV and cable operators are offering VOD services. Mac users just cant access those services.
By not supporting DRM on Macintosh platform, Microsoft puts high pressure on Macintosh users.
Robert, good luck. I think it will be a cold day in H3ll before your boss lets you distribute content in a non-Microsoft proprietary format. Your employer is in the business of cramming Windows down the public's throat.
I used to be happy running WMP files in mplayer, but lately (maybe it is the WMP10 codecs or whatever), video is missing, or audio plays back at chipmunk speed.
"Real Mac users can spot a poorly ported App from a mile away."
That's funny - as primarily a Windows user, that's just how I feel about the sluggish non-standards-conforming behemoth that is iTunes for Windows :-)
>> "That’s funny - as primarily a Windows user, that’s just how I feel about the sluggish non-standards-conforming behemoth that is iTunes for Windows"
Neither company can claim that their players are particularly well-optimized, but at least iTunes on Windows retains full functionality and is pretty much the same user experience on Windows and MacOS.
WMP on OSX? Total and utter abortion, missing features, completely foreign interface, etc. Neither cross-platform player is great, but only WMP on OSX is TERRIBLE.
And then they wonder why Apple customers don't complain when Apple comes out with all these proprietary lock-in solutions like ITMS.
BECAUSE IF APPLE DOESN'T TAKE CARE OF THEIR CUSTOMERS NO ONE ELSE WILL!. All the big media companies are contractually obligated to suck at the teat of Microsoft and Microsoft doesn't care
I've purchased about 15 Windows based DRM music files from WalMart and Napster. Can't play them natively on my Mac so I have to burn them to CD and import them. Tell me Microsoft, how is that supporting your customers?
I can't go to Movielink and download any movies or shows because WMP on OS X doesn't support the DRM.
Once again, Apple "Gets it" and Microsoft doesn't. I can buy any content at ITMS and play it on either my Windows or OS X box. Heck, I don't even have to copy the file to my OS X box. I can just connect to my shared music and play it. Can't do that with WMP on Windows can I?
That's why ITMS gets my money and Walmart/Napster/Yahoo don't.
Microsoft Drops WMP for Mac OS X, Adds a Keyboard
After the Apple/Microsoft love fest at Macworld, two unexpected events revealed that maybe relations between the companies aren't as rosy as they'd like us to believe. First, Microsoft dropped its Windows Media Player for Mac software, and is now pushing customers to download a third party plug-in that supports Windows Media audio and video formats in Apple's QuickTime Player. Apparently, the issue is Microsoft's Digital Rights Management (DRM)-protected audio and video files; Apple wouldn't provide the technical details Microsoft needed to support the formats on OS X, so Microsoft just gave up.
Right now, I have VLC, QuickTime, RealPlayer and Windows Media Player all installed on my Mac, with each playing a different subset of media formats. It would be nice if I could just have one.
(Incidently I have 3 of those on Windows too, RealPlayer being the exception since I use Real Alternative instead).
We're lucky to have a media framework like QuickTime at all since M$ once put pressure on Apple to "knife the baby" (kill quicktime). Yet another example of how M$ is anti-consumer.
Quicktime plugins is the right way to support media formats on the mac because then the formats are usable in all apps. So maybe this is M$ waking up and realizing that the baby is now a strapping young warrior.
This kind of decisions are quite difficult to understand, because Roos was on the stage tell us that the MacBU was going for another 5 years, and then they cut one application, you didn't realize if Microsoft is focusing just on Office (Office Pro Includes Virtual PC and any version on Office includes Messenger)
But the real question is if it will be possible to provide the DRM and "Plays for Sure" functionality.
Except where it counts the most: DRM.
If you can't open the file because of DRM, it doesn't matter how much "better" the player might be, does it now?
That's NOT factually true.
Flip4Mac simply does not support DRM...
Whether MS drops support for Windows Media Player v9 for Mac in the not too distant future, it is still available for now and probably will be in the timeframe that any of the supported formats are still relevant.
That's somehow news to you? Oy Vey, that's not surprising. The WM team has always been willing to let the Mac BU catch hell for their substandard work. What I would hope is they work with the Flip4Mac people to get more current WM support.
Yes, I know, that's never going to happen. BallmerGates wants you to have to be on Windows to have anything but a craptacular WM experience. I'd say it will happen at the same time as they put Office on Linux. Same day even, i'll call it:
The Fifth of Never.
Other bugs, for the most part, aren't bugs. I think people confuse compatibility with certain web links not working as bugs, when in fact there are many different media protocols, formats and nertwork variances which will take some time to accomodate on the F4M side.
DRM? Compatibility IS coming. Every manufacturer of software has a feature request list. F4M is no different, and it will add the most desired features.
Unfortunately, version 1.0.x was pretty much the same. I experienced numerous crashes and other glitches with it :-\