Scobleizer: How about a comment-based Memeorandum?
Daniel Nicolas
· 3 years ago
Flickr has feeds for just about everything BUT the "your popular photos" sections, which does everything like you are talking about, but it's not public and is only your photos. Good call. I bet it wouldn't be that much work for them to implement what you're talking about (or for someone else to build something really cool that is like that), but clearly there is opportunity waiting for someone to strike.
William Strathearn
· 3 years ago
This reminds me of the difference between YouTube.com's most viewed video list and most discussed video list. The most viewed list contains a lot of videos with inticing titles, screen caps and tags, but the videos most commented on are usually much more interesting and substantial.
In this case, an article's link inside another blog's post could be considered just as significant as a comment by a reader. Both require thought and effort, both reference the original post. It seems like Memorandum should take comments into account, but I would'nt imgine that a list of posts ranked by comment count are any more interesting than those ranked by linkage.
Stefan Constantinescu
· 3 years ago
Wouldn't work since meme's content get's changed every 5 minutes. What's hot one hour is gone the next.
I still plead with my battle cry for someone to develop an RSS reader that has a meme engine in it to see everything that is crosslinked, quoted, and talked about.
One can only dream!
anon
· 3 years ago
Sploggers thank you for such a great idea, Scoble.
Tejas Patel
· 3 years ago
As Stefan said, it will have to check for website/blog updates every 30 seconds or so which is not really cool and not all posts are hot when they are on Memeorandum, some get hotter when they are off memeo..
Graham Chastney
· 3 years ago
Yes please. I think that those search people have a long, long way to go to show us the stuff that we want to see and this looks like one of the pieces.
met
· 3 years ago
The posts that get commented the most are usually Google, Mac and Microsoft ones. So just do a keyword search for those three.
Kevin Burton
· 3 years ago
We'll soon support Delicious and Simpy for tuning ranking and comments are already a factor in TailRank.
They'll have more importance here soon as I'm about to push some robot updates.
Kevin
Devin Reams
· 3 years ago
Why don't we do away with comments and just blog our responses? Like Matt's 'asides' in WordPress, just make ourselves a 'Comments' category and stick them somewhere less prominent (or not in the feed). Wait, this is a comment isn't it? Damn hard habit to break...
TDavid
· 3 years ago
To add to what Tejas said above ...
As a publisher I'd much rather push out comment data to a few places - like pinging - rather than a fury of bots hitting our site sucking down the same info. The bigger your site gets, the more popular, the more stress you get from bots. It's already an insane ratio of bots to people, especially if you do any podcasting.
A system that invites even more bot activity to a single non-aggregated source when the payoff in traffic is marginal (Google, Yahoo, MSN and a few other bots aside) seems very resource intensive with little payoff.
If the SE bots want to come more often, we'd welcome that of course :)
what
· 3 years ago
yeeh. it's called slashdot?
Adam
· 3 years ago
I respectfully disagree with that idea, Robert.
It's a self-perpetuating loop... a VERY common mistake in a lot of Web services. By highlighting what's popular, you simply entice more people to access that particular article or resource, thus making it more popular. That's why "Top 10" lists tend to be, at least over time, stultifyingly boring.
All Comments
Good call. I bet it wouldn't be that much work for them to implement what you're talking about (or for someone else to build something really cool that is like that), but clearly there is opportunity waiting for someone to strike.
In this case, an article's link inside another blog's post could be considered just as significant as a comment by a reader. Both require thought and effort, both reference the original post. It seems like Memorandum should take comments into account, but I would'nt imgine that a list of posts ranked by comment count are any more interesting than those ranked by linkage.
I still plead with my battle cry for someone to develop an RSS reader that has a meme engine in it to see everything that is crosslinked, quoted, and talked about.
One can only dream!
They'll have more importance here soon as I'm about to push some robot updates.
Kevin
As a publisher I'd much rather push out comment data to a few places - like pinging - rather than a fury of bots hitting our site sucking down the same info. The bigger your site gets, the more popular, the more stress you get from bots. It's already an insane ratio of bots to people, especially if you do any podcasting.
A system that invites even more bot activity to a single non-aggregated source when the payoff in traffic is marginal (Google, Yahoo, MSN and a few other bots aside) seems very resource intensive with little payoff.
If the SE bots want to come more often, we'd welcome that of course :)
It's a self-perpetuating loop... a VERY common mistake in a lot of Web services. By highlighting what's popular, you simply entice more people to access that particular article or resource, thus making it more popular. That's why "Top 10" lists tend to be, at least over time, stultifyingly boring.