I agree sort of, yes Jaiku has the aggregation features (aka social streams), but a major part of it is the twitter like functionality of giving status updates.
In it's current form I do see it as a competitor to twitter, but it will be interesting to see what they do around the corner what with Google on board.
But no, Jaiku will never really be able to 'defeat' twitter.
Twitter deserves to die. It's dysfunctional, down a lot, and their error messages are lies. No improvements. No bug fixes. Their "upgrades" are vaporware.
Twitter has crappy "in reply to" that links to the most recent tweet, rather than a specific tweet of a Twitterer.
Twitter is a frustrating tool that just gets worse all the time, not better.
Jaiku will and should kill Twitter. Good riddance.
Seth E
· 2 years ago
But then Jaiku/Google should get Twitter to work right on top of it. With today's buzz and all the activity and new adds going on at Jaiku, I've had to keep switching between services--not to mention my "real work" just to stay on top of everything and communicate with friends. I wish Jaiku built was some Twitterific-like application that could let me use everything and interact with all feeds at once. That's the direction GOOG needs to move it in, somekind of Seth-homebase.
Ronald Lewis
· 2 years ago
I just awoke to the news of Google's acquisition. I'm already tired of the discussions on Twitter. It's great for Jaiku, but now people are going apeshit because of it.
David Jacobs
· 2 years ago
I don't believe the Facebook killer tech Google will roll out Nov 5. It will most likely be very interesting and helpful to all social networks, maybe even Facebook, but from what I've seen of Orkut so far, they've got nothing on Facebook yet.
Google is looking a little more like Microsoft every day; bigger, slower, more confused. Even in the online app space, Zoho is outdoing Google in several ways.
BarbaraKB
· 2 years ago
What about Pownce? Jaiku with Google makes me want to peacefully leave Pownce. Love the file sharing at Pownce: photos, videos, links, events but Jaiku has as well. LOVE the little photo is a post element. Jaiku is stronger in Asia and Europe and while I don't think it will *kill* Twitter, it might *force* Twitter to do some things better.
James Pearce
· 2 years ago
Twitter is a stream of text, or at best a stream of consiousness.
Jaiku is a stream of context and a stream of presence.
That's why the latter is a glimpse of the future of a (mobile) web.
Raimo
· 2 years ago
This move helps Google jump into the Mobile LIVE web. All the current social services(next to Gtalk) miss the LIVE element to make it succesful in the mobile space. Jaiku is positioned perfectly to help Google's existing endeavours into the mobile space. Don't forget this. Jaiku is a bridge between content and communication. Two worlds now in Google.. See my post: http://marikaya.wordpress.com/2007/10/09/google...
FSFunky
· 2 years ago
I'm sticking with twitter... Jaiku is too much for me. Less is more people.
You can feed your Twitter tweets through Jaiku. Jaiku has good threaded conversation via comments for specific messages.
Folks, that is an immense improvement and benefit making Jaiku far superior to Twitter.
Twitter is hit or miss conversationing. Jaiku is precision conversationing.
Michael Bailey
· 2 years ago
TV Killed The Radio Star -
uhm, okay, and now back to reality. None of the events today, or the predictions of tomorrow are going to matter to my bottom line in any shape or form.
Tomorrow will bring another shiny object, something which we can all rally around and invoke our emotions upon.
Over time, life will grab a hold of us again and we'll move on to discussions of things which really matter.
At least, I certainly hope that happens.
Shaine
· 2 years ago
What keeps me with Twitter are my Twitter friends. Also, that I get charged for using international SMS numbers.
For all its RSS might, whenever you Google me, my Jaiku account never comes up; so much for presence.
I wrote about How to Kill Facebook. Maybe Google has the way to start building an open social network that will be our personal channels for our content. They've got video, RSS, blogs, and now a Twitter-esque service. Imagine combining all your content and attaching it to a person. Imagine being able to search all the content from a specific person across platforms.
I'm not particularly thrilled with Jaiku, but it may lead the way to putting all your content under one roof. One searchable presence.
INFINITY PRO: "NEENZ"
· 2 years ago
JAIKU does have all the features already mentioned which makes it good for presence.
TWITTER has all of the people.
The people trumps features.
Especially since, I still have yet to receive the code to activate my phone.
Until then, I shall feed Jaiku my twitters and RSS feeds. And of course the random Jaiku to post something clever on my FB.
Thank you Scob!
william
· 2 years ago
Yes Jaiku mobile client rocks - if you have the one phone that can run it - oh, and if you are overseas.
David Jacobs
· 2 years ago
Correct Infinity Pro, it's all about critical mass and right now Twitter has it. As technology people we need to learn out lesson, more features doesn't mean better. Apple creates products that people love, but they don't generally have as many raw features as Microsoft products. People don't want all the features, they want something that works really well. I could teach my mom to use Twitter, I'm not so sure about Jaiku.
Ian Delaney
· 2 years ago
Forgive me for saying this, but the US is still finding its feet on mobile apps, whereas Europe is crying out for them, and also for mobile ad inventory. Perfect match, I'd say.
Esme Vos
· 2 years ago
I also prefer Jaiku to Twitter, primarily for its mobile application and RSS feed aggregation. As for Twitter having all the people - it depends where you live. A lot of Europeans are on Jaiku, whereas Twitter has a bigger user base in the US. At least that's the sense I get. Am I right?
Kris Gainsforth
· 2 years ago
I don't see Jaiku causing major issues with Twitter. Google's best play here is to use it to integrate GrandCentral, Reader, and Gmail better via mobile. Maybe even YouTube, but for the basics, I still use Twitter, and I'm not dropping it, but I am a Jaikuholic due to the ease of seeing replies and getting into conversations quicker.
Joe
· 2 years ago
Good point about Google buying companies and then you never hear from them again. Like Picasa, Blogger, YouTube, Writley, Urchin.
Twitter's dead.
MMartin
· 2 years ago
Google was late in Social Networking. They recently released Google Shared Stuff (a del.icio.us-like) and now bring Jaiku in the wagon. Great move. They should now begin to play on Myspace/Facebook playground.
Chris Gonyea
· 2 years ago
Not to mention Google Earth. That wasn't developed in house.
Jaiku is prettier and thta's all it counts for me.
btw, been waiting for jotspot over a year now, HURRY UP GODDAMNIT!
SunkenShip
· 2 years ago
Facebook is sinking, on november 5th it will be on the bottom of the aleutians!
SELL!
monk.e.boy
· 2 years ago
> Imagine if Google made a more open social networking > tool than Facebook all via RSS feeds? Stick that into > your RSS feed reader and smoke it!
The most interesting thing you've said so far.
Imagine linking this with a "believability - expert - I trust this person - reputation" score (like eBay feedback) and OpenID and you have a cool distributed eBay type of social network, where spam just sort of disappears. And interesting people rise to the top.
I hate the fact that my eBay reputation is great, but I modded 'troll' in slashdot. Don't they know I'm reputable?! ;-)
But it'd work on all sorts of platforms (could we hook in facebook RSS + myspace RSS into it as well?)...
I like that idea.
wikipedia: wuffie
Nice post. Keep it up Scoble!
monk.e.boy
Shree
· 2 years ago
You are right, Google buys everything and dumps it pretty much. But at the same time it's gaining traction in terms of new accounts - transferred from dodgeball etc to google. So, it's culling any competition, while taking adavantage. But, I certainly hope it's not going to kill Jaiku.
Evisu
· 2 years ago
LOL Google has the buck to buy everything.
The Microblogger
· 2 years ago
I don't think the concept of microblogging itself can die, either with twitter or jaiku. Both are now positioned to take advantages in different domains. Jaiku is slated to become the mobile twitter from the gPhone in its due course, and Twitter still rules the roost in text simplicity, and the social need to shout-out is going to remain forever.
I am an avid microblogger, and have an account on twitter, as well as an Indian site chittR, which also scores in simplicity and UI. Bet its an alpha, but works pretty well in cross platform.
I would wait for Jaiku to figure in the gPhone and also looking forward for Google's answer to facebook in November
All Comments
In it's current form I do see it as a competitor to twitter, but it will be interesting to see what they do around the corner what with Google on board.
But no, Jaiku will never really be able to 'defeat' twitter.
http://luke.gedeon.name/what-ever-happened-to-j...
Twitter has crappy "in reply to" that links to the most recent tweet, rather than a specific tweet of a Twitterer.
Twitter is a frustrating tool that just gets worse all the time, not better.
Jaiku will and should kill Twitter. Good riddance.
Google is looking a little more like Microsoft every day; bigger, slower, more confused. Even in the online app space, Zoho is outdoing Google in several ways.
Jaiku is a stream of context and a stream of presence.
That's why the latter is a glimpse of the future of a (mobile) web.
http://marikaya.wordpress.com/2007/10/09/google...
on twitter
Folks, that is an immense improvement and benefit making Jaiku far superior to Twitter.
Twitter is hit or miss conversationing. Jaiku is precision conversationing.
uhm, okay, and now back to reality.
None of the events today, or the predictions of tomorrow are going to matter to my bottom line in any shape or form.
Tomorrow will bring another shiny object, something which we can all rally around and invoke our emotions upon.
Over time, life will grab a hold of us again and we'll move on to discussions of things which really matter.
At least, I certainly hope that happens.
For all its RSS might, whenever you Google me, my Jaiku account never comes up; so much for presence.
I wrote about How to Kill Facebook. Maybe Google has the way to start building an open social network that will be our personal channels for our content. They've got video, RSS, blogs, and now a Twitter-esque service. Imagine combining all your content and attaching it to a person. Imagine being able to search all the content from a specific person across platforms.
I'm not particularly thrilled with Jaiku, but it may lead the way to putting all your content under one roof. One searchable presence.
TWITTER has all of the people.
The people trumps features.
Especially since, I still have yet to receive the code to activate my phone.
Until then, I shall feed Jaiku my twitters and RSS feeds. And of course the random Jaiku to post something clever on my FB.
Thank you Scob!
Twitter's dead.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_Earth
http://www.harael.com/2007/09/google-should-bui...
btw, been waiting for jotspot over a year now, HURRY UP GODDAMNIT!
SELL!
> tool than Facebook all via RSS feeds? Stick that into
> your RSS feed reader and smoke it!
The most interesting thing you've said so far.
Imagine linking this with a "believability - expert - I trust this person - reputation" score (like eBay feedback) and OpenID and you have a cool distributed eBay type of social network, where spam just sort of disappears. And interesting people rise to the top.
I hate the fact that my eBay reputation is great, but I modded 'troll' in slashdot. Don't they know I'm reputable?! ;-)
But it'd work on all sorts of platforms (could we hook in facebook RSS + myspace RSS into it as well?)...
I like that idea.
wikipedia: wuffie
Nice post. Keep it up Scoble!
monk.e.boy
I am an avid microblogger, and have an account on twitter, as well as an Indian site chittR, which also scores in simplicity and UI. Bet its an alpha, but works pretty well in cross platform.
I would wait for Jaiku to figure in the gPhone and also looking forward for Google's answer to facebook in November